Review handling and quotation permissions

Every use of a critique has its own authority.

A review is not automatically a blurb. Private editorial use, confidential circulation to agents or publishers, and public quotation remain distinct decisions stored with the submission.

Required

Editorial and factual use

The author may use the critique and private notes to assess, correct, and improve the work and its companion materials.

Required

Secure storage and complete email copies

The complete submission is stored in the secure project system and sent to the reviewer and author as a record of what was submitted.

Optional

Confidential trade circulation

The reviewer may permit all or part of the critique—but never private notes—to be shared privately with literary agents, publishers, editors, or other publishing professionals.

Optional

Public quotation

The reviewer may separately allow selected exact quotations on the website or in general promotional materials under the chosen attribution.

No permission by implication

Submitting a critique does not authorize confidential trade circulation or public quotation unless the corresponding optional box is selected. The author may later ask separately for additional permission.

Honest public record

No fabricated review, sample praise, or simulated academic endorsement.

Only responses from real identified or anonymously attributed reviewers, received through the portal and used under their recorded permissions, may enter the public record.

Request review access Independent critical review

The complete literary cycle

Postlude

The Postlude brings the Unreliable Editor, Zeitblom, and A Fellow Wayfarer back to their table. The account is finished. Their responsibility for it is not. In twelve sections, the desire to make a life complete becomes a bargain the writers must recognize in themselves.

Postlude The books